An independent, official review of the first version
"I've seen a lot ... but there's nothing that comes close to MagicWB in quality"
(by Thomas Baetzler)
I will admit I had to be forced to try out the MagicWB package. I had
been using the normal 4 color HighRes Workbench for ages, and I saw no need
to change things around, especially not to some colorful interlaced mode.
But then my Picasso II arrived, and peer pressure got the better of me. Now
I'm perfectly happy with the new look of my Workbench, and I'm not thinking
of switching back any more. (..)
Modifications [to your system by MagicWB] include the switch to an
interlaced display [i.e. proportional, 640x480 etc.] with eight colors.
Also, all of the standard system icons will be replaced with their MagicWB
counterparts. The supplied utility "Update Drawers" brings the new "Magic"
look to directory structures on other partitions of your system. Once
you're done, you will see the new professional look of your Workbench.
MagicWB also comes with a large collection of nice-looking backdrops that
can be installed on your Workbench. They sure do look nice, but if your
Workbench version is lower than 3.0, you need NickPrefs to install them. (..)
You pay for all that glitz with some trade-offs: the MagicWB icons are
quite a bit larger in size than the old ones, so they take up much more
space on your hard disk. (..)
Switching from 4 colors non-interlaced to 8 colors interlaced also carries
some performance penalties on older systems, since the increased DMA
bandwidth required to display such a mode effectively slows down blitter
operation [this does not affect Amigas with AGA or a graphic board]. (..)
Running MagicWB on my Picasso II graphics board in 800x600 pixel
resolution is a pleasure to behold! (..)
If you don't have the AGA chipset, I strongly recommend a flicker fixer or
some kind of graphics board that lets you use the Workbench in a flicker
free HighRes-Interlaced or better display mode. While MagicWB can be
installed on any kind of system, it doesn't look too good on displays with
non-proportional pixels. For example, a 640x200 display would make the
MagicWB icons look much too tall. (..) The MagicWB icons are created using the
enhanced AmigaDOS 2.x coloring scheme, so you'll need at least Workbench
MagicWB gives your Amiga Workbench that professional look that you've come
to envy on systems like NeXT. You really should give it a try. I'd rate
it 4.5 stars out of 5.